We’re Back! Once again, we’re ready to help you bring some Michael’s Dairy to your holiday celebrations.


We’re making a limited quantity of Michael’s Dairy Ice Cream Pies for pre-order. Pick up will be at the Dairy on Tuesday December 19, 2023 from 3pm – 7pm.



Our pies are 9” in diameter with your choice of graham or chocolate pie crust. Each pie is hand-filled with some of your favorite Michael’s Dairy ice cream and adorned with festive toppings. We pack each pie into a white carrying box with window top to show off the yumminess inside.


Remaining Ice Cream Pie Flavor Choices (while supplies last):
Butter Pecan
Chocolate Chip
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup (limited)
Coconut (limited)
Coffee Toffee
Monster Mash
Pink Peppermint (limited)
Pumpkin Oreo
SB Cheesecake

All pies are $24.99 and are only guaranteed by pre-ordering. Click Here To Order


Want a little extra ice cream in the freezer? All quarts and pints of ice cream will be sold at 50% off in-season costs.


We ALSO are offering build-your-own local beverage gift packs. We’ll give you a cute white-colored 6-pack gift box and you can fill it with your choice of 6 local beverages including Hosmer Sodas, Schooner’s Iced Teas and Lemonades, and more. We’ll even give you a festive bow to stick on your gift box.


And – if you have a Mitchell College fan on your gift list this season, you can place an order on our on-campus Gear Shop website and it will be ready for your to pick up at the Dairy on the same day. (CLICK HERE FOR GEAR SHOP)

Hope to see you soon!